Anatomy of Singapore's outbreak

COVID-19

Anatomy of Singapore's outbreak

How the virus spread through migrant worker dormitories
Cases on
23 Jan
Very early cases of the virus were mostly imported into Singapore
Local transmission began in February and clusters of infections began to emerge
In April, a large number of foreign workers began to get infected causing many dormitory clusters
S11 Dormitory
Sungei Tengah Lodge
Tuas View Dormitory
Westlite Toh Guan
Mandai Lodge I
Mustafa Centre
31 Sungei Kadut Avenue
Grace Assembly
of God cluster
SAFRA club dinner
Sparkletots preschool

Once held up as a role model for its battle against coronavirus, city-state Singapore has struggled to contain an infection spread that is now centred around foreign worker dormitories, construction sites and factories.

The animation above shows every infection and how the virus formed clusters as it made its way through the Southeast Asian island nation in the early stages of the outbreak. The Ministry of Health stopped reporting case-level data on April 19, but the explosion in dormitory cases had become evident by that time.

More than 300,000 foreign labourers, mainly from Bangladesh, China and India, live in dormitories, in rooms equipped with bunks for 12 to 20 men who work jobs that pay as little as $14 a day.

From April 20, as the number of cases began to rise dramatically, the Ministry of Health stopped publishing granular detail on individual cases but did report aggregated figures and some information on clusters. The scale of the dormitory problem remained clear.

Cases on
20 Apr
0
Imported cases
0
Dormitory cases
0
Other local cases

Reuters counted at least 210 clusters of infection from daily data released by the health ministry since the start of the outbreak in January. Following the dramatic increase in dormitory cases over the past few weeks, the majority of cases are located at dorms or industrial addresses.

The majority of foreign labourers in Singapore stay at one of the 43 purpose-built dormitories in Singapore, housing 200,000 workers. There are also 1,200 converted factories housing 95,000 workers and various other smaller temporary quarters, according to the Ministry of Manpower.

The largest cluster by far comes from the sprawling dormitory complex called S11 @Punggol. The company which owns the complex advertises the “cheapest dormitories in Singapore.”

The dormitory can house up to 14,000 workers in four-storey buildings on about 5.8 hectares, roughly the same area as eight soccer pitches, according to local media reports.

Dormitory clusters

Each group of dots

represents a cluster of

infections as of May 17

S11 Dormitory

2,577 cases

Sungei Tengah

Lodge

Tuas View

Dormitory

Jurong Penjuru

Dormitory

North Coast Lodge

Changi Lodge II

Mandai

Lodge

Kranji Lodge 1

Westlite Mandai

Seatown

Dormitory

Hulett

Dormitory

Cochrane Lodge II

CDPL Tuas

Dormitory

Other identifiable dormitories

Not listed as purpose-built

by Ministry of Manpower

Industrial addresses

The majority are factories which either house

workers or have been converted into dorms.

Construction sites

Many of the workers in dormitories work in construction and some clusters have formed at building sites. Some cases appear in more than one cluster, meaning they both live and work in places with outbreaks. All construction work was stopped April 7 in order to combat the spread.

The Jovell

Community clusters

Clusters in local communities are few and small compared to those in the dormitories. There are only four small clusters in food and beverage outlets.

Education

Community

Food and beverage

Places of

worship

Workplace

Retail

Each group of dots

represents a cluster of

infections as of May 17

S11 Dormitory

2,577 cases

Sungei Tengah Lodge

1,838 cases

Tuas View Dormitory

1,285 cases

Jurong Penjuru

Dormitory

North Coast Lodge

Changi Lodge II

Mandai

Lodge

Kranji Lodge 1

Westlite Mandai

Seatown

Dormitory

Hulett

Dormitory

Cochrane Lodge II

CDPL Tuas

Dormitory

Other identifiable dormitories

Not listed as purpose-built

by Ministry of Manpower

SJ

Dormitory

Industrial addresses

The majority of these locations are factories which

either house workers or have been converted into dorms.

61 Senoko Drive

31 Sungei

Kadut Ave

21B Senoko

Loop

Construction sites

The majority of the workers in dormitories work in construction and some clusters have formed at building sites. Some cases appear in more than one cluster, meaning they both live and work in places with outbreaks. All construction work was stopped April 7 in order to combat the spread.

The Jovell

Project Glory

Community clusters

Clusters in local communities are few and small compared to those in the dormitories. There are only four small clusters in food and beverage outlets.

Education

Community

Food and beverage

Places of worship

Retail outlets

Workplace

Each group of dots

represents a cluster of

infections as of May 17

S11 Dormitory

2,577 cases

Sungei Tengah Lodge

1,838 cases

Tuas View Dormitory

1,285 cases

Jurong Penjuru

Dormitory

North Coast Lodge

Changi Lodge II

Mandai

Lodge

Kranji Lodge 1

Westlite Mandai

Seatown

Dormitory

Hulett

Dormitory

Cochrane Lodge II

CDPL Tuas

Dormitory

Other identifiable dormitories

Not listed as purpose-built

by Ministry of Manpower

SJ

Dormitory

Industrial addresses

The majority of these locations are factories which

either house workers or have been converted into dorms.

61 Senoko Drive

31 Sungei

Kadut Ave

21B Senoko

Loop

11 Tech Park

Crescent

Construction sites

The majority of the workers in dormitories work in construction and some clusters have formed at building sites. Some cases appear in more than one cluster, meaning they both live and work in places with outbreaks. All construction work was stopped April 7 in order to combat the spread.

The Jovell

Project Glory

6 Battery Road

Community clusters

Clusters in local communities are few and small compared to those in the dormitories. There are only four small clusters in food and beverage outlets.

Education

Community

Food and beverage

SAFRA Jurong

dinner

Lee Ah Mooi

care home

Places of worship

Retail outlets

Workplace

Sembawang

Shipyard

Grace Assembly

of God

Mustafa Centre

Each group of dots

represents a cluster of

infections as of May 17

S11 Dormitory

2,577 cases

Sungei Tengah

Lodge

Tuas View

Dormitory

Jurong Penjuru

Dormitory

Other identifiable dormitories

Not listed as purpose-built

by Ministry of Manpower

Industrial addresses

The majority are factories which either house

workers or have been converted into dorms.

Construction sites

Many of the workers in dormitories work in construction and some clusters have formed at building sites. Some cases appear in more than one cluster, meaning they both live and work in places with outbreaks. All construction work was stopped April 7 in order to combat the spread.

Community clusters

Clusters in local communities are few and small compared to those in the dormitories. There are only four small clusters in food and beverage outlets.

Education

Community

Food and beverage

Places of

worship

Retail

Workplace

Each group of dots

represents a cluster of

infections as of May 17

S11 Dormitory

2,577 cases

Seatown

Dormitory

Changi Lodge II

Sungei Tengah Lodge

1,838 cases

Tuas View Dormitory

1,285 cases

North Coast Lodge

Jurong Penjuru

Dormitory

Westlite Mandai

Hulett

Dormitory

Mandai

Lodge

Kranji Lodge 1

Cochrane Lodge II

CDPL Tuas

Dormitory

Other identifiable dormitories

Not listed as purpose-built

by Ministry of Manpower

SJ

Dormitory

Industrial addresses

The majority of these locations are factories which

either house workers or have been converted into dorms.

61 Senoko Drive

31 Sungei

Kadut Ave

21B Senoko

Loop

11 Tech Park

Crescent

Construction sites

The majority of the workers in dormitories work in construction and some clusters have formed at building sites. Some cases appear in more than one cluster, meaning they both live and work in places with outbreaks. All construction work was stopped April 7 in order to combat the spread.

The Jovell

Project Glory

6 Battery Road

Community clusters

Clusters in local communities are few and small compared to those in the dormitories. There are only four small clusters in food and beverage outlets.

Education

Community

Food and beverage

SAFRA

dinner

Lee Ah Mooi

care home

Places of worship

Workplace

Retail outlets

Grace Assembly

of God

Sembawang

Shipyard

Mustafa Centre

Concentration of clusters

Some of Singapore’s clusters in the wider community and those at construction sites are more evenly distributed across the island. However, the rest are located on the fringes of the modern city-state, industrial areas little visited by tourists where land is cheap. Most dormitory residents work in the construction industry, which in just over half a century has transformed Singapore from colonial backwater to gleaming metropolis. Others work in shipyards or preen the gardens of luxury condominiums.

Sembawang

MALAYSIA

S11 dormitory

2,577 cases

Woodlands

SINGAPORE

Changi

Airport

Tuas

Downtown

As of May 17

Dormitory and

industrial clusters

Other clusters

2 km

Sembawang

MALAYSIA

S11 dormitory

2,577 cases

Woodlands

SINGAPORE

Changi

Airport

Tuas

Downtown

As of May 17

Dormitory and

industrial clusters

Other clusters

2 km

Johor Bahru

2 km

MALAYSIA

Sembawang

Woodlands

Sungei

Kadut

S11 dormitory

2,577 cases

Sungei Tengah

Lodge cluster

1,838 cases

SINGAPORE

Tuas South

32 clusters at

dorms and

industrial areas

Changi

Airport

Kaki Bukit

industrial area

Boon Lay

Downtown

Tuas

As of May 17

Dormitory and industrial clusters

Other clusters

Johor Bahru

MALAYSIA

Sembawang

2 km

Woodlands

Sungei

Kadut

S11 dormitory

2,577 cases

Sungei Tengah

Lodge cluster

1,838 cases

SINGAPORE

Tuas South

32 clusters at

dorms and

industrial areas

Changi

Airport

Tuas

Kaki Bukit

industrial area

Boon Lay

Downtown

As of May 17

Dormitory and industrial clusters

Other clusters

As of May 17

Dormitory and industrial clusters

Other clusters

29 clusters at dormitories

and industrial addresses

Johor Bahru

MALAYSIA

Sembawang

2 km

Woodlands

Sungei

Kadut

Kranji

S11 dormitory

2,577 cases

Sungei Tengah

Lodge cluster

1,838 cases

SINGAPORE

Tuas South

32 clusters at

dorms and

industrial areas

Changi

Airport

Tuas

Kaki Bukit

industrial area

Boon Lay

Downtown

The government has said that the situation in the dormitories has stabilised and has committed to testing all dormitory residents over the coming months as it looks to get people back to work and reopen its economy. Yet with hundreds of new cases still being reported each day, the tiny city-state of just 5.7 million now has one of the highest infection rates in Asia – underlining the scale of the challenge of keeping the coronavirus at bay even in countries praised for their response.

By Manas Sharma and Simon Scarr

Sources: Ministry of Health, Singapore; Ministry of Manpower, Singapore